32.1 C
Friday, September 22, 2023

SC Quashes HC Verdict Regarding 3% Sports Quota In Medical

New Delhi: Observing that the courts can’t problem writs to provide quota, the Supreme Court on Tuesday set apart a part of the verdict of the Punjab and Haryana High Court directing the Punjab government to offer three, as opposed to one, percentage reservation under sports activities category in nation-run medical and dental schools.

The verdict of the pinnacle court came on the enchantment of the Punjab authorities against the 2019 not unusual judgment of the High Court directing issuance of fresh notification for providing for a sports activities quota of three percent, instead of one percentage determined by the government, in government-run medical and dental faculties of the nation.

The High Court had said that a one percent quota is supplied for “youngsters/grandchildren of terrorist affected persons/Sikh riots affected individuals in all personal unaided non-minority Medical/Dental institutions inside the country”.

It had also directed the reservation for terrorist and riots affected applicants shall observe to the management seats as nicely.


A bench comprising Justices M R Shah and B V Nagarathna dealt in element with the validity of the High Court order enhancing the sports activities quota from one to a few percent in government clinical and dental faculties and decided no longer to cope with the other issue of the decision.

The query of whether the excessive court docket turned into proper in providing one percent quota for youngsters or grandchildren of terrorist or riots affected humans in admissions has become “academic” because the country has now furnished the reservation, the judgment stated, adding that the “question of regulation” would stay open.

“So away as the second one route issued with the aid of the High Court directing to offer for a sports quota of 3 percentage in Government Medical/Dental Colleges inside the State of Punjab is concerned, the equal is hereby quashed and set aside by gazing that no writ of mandamus might have been issued by using the High Court,” it stated.

Dealing with the part of the high court order improving sports quota, the bench mentioned diverse apex court docket verdicts and said, “No writ of mandamus may be issued via the court directing the State Government to provide for reservation”.


“We are of the opinion that the High Court has committed a grave mistake in issuing a writ of mandamus and directing the State Government to provide for 3 reservation/quota for sportspersons, in preference to one percent as supplied by means of the State Government.

“An aware coverage decision turned into taken through the State Government to provide for one percentage reservation/quota for sportspersons.

Therefore, the High Court has handed its jurisdiction whilst issuing a writ of mandamus directing the State to offer a particular percent of reservation for sportspersons..,” the 20-web page judgment said whilst quashing the “unsustainable” High Court verdict.

Justice Shah, writing the judgment, said a conscious policy selection was taken through the national government to offer for the simplest one percent reservation/quota for sportspersons.


Earlier, numerous pleas have been filed inside the excessive court difficult the government’s notification on 2019 by using which “one percentage reservation for sportspersons; one percent reservation for youngsters/grandchildren of terrorist affected persons and one percent reservation for youngsters/grandchildren of Sikh riot-affected persons in the State quota seats in authorities institutions” were furnished.

The High Court had allowed the pleas and had issued numerous guidelines inclusive of enhancing the sports activities quota from one to a few percent.

Related Stories

Most Popular Articles